Hon. Milton Mollen '50L, '78HON Is a Paragon of Justice

June 14, 2010

When Milton Mollen graduated cum laude from St. John's School of Law 60 years ago, his plans were the same as those of many new attorneys.  Joined by two of his fellow School of Law graduates, he established a private practice and prepared to devote his career to utilizing his talents in the name of justice, one client at a time. A career in public service was the farthest thing from his mind, but that was soon to change.

An attorney for whom Mollen had done special research as a student had been named Corporation Counsel for the City of New York, and offered him a position within that esteemed office. Mollen's initial reaction was to remain in private practice, but he finally decided to accept the position on a short-term basis. "I initially agreed to take the position with the Corporation Counsel because I thought it would be interesting to spend some time working for the city," he recalled. "When my colleagues and friends asked me why I would leave private practice, I told them that I was only going to do it for two years to get some litigation experience that would help me in my own practice. Little did I know that I would be in public service for the next 42 years."

Mollen's more than four decades in pursuit of justice for the people of  New York began in 1952 with his appointment as Assistant Corporation Counsel in the General Litigation Division, after which he was promoted Acting Chief of the General Litigation Division, then Chief of the Penalties Division and finally Executive Assistant Corporation Counsel.

"Even though I wasn't planning to stay in public service, I started to go up the ladder and kept getting promoted," he said. "I began to enjoy having some great opportunities to do things that wouldn't have been available to me otherwise."

In 1968 Mollen embarked upon a distinguished career in the judiciary when he became a Judge of the Criminal Court. He later served as Justice of the Supreme Court of the State of New York, Associate Justice of the Appellate Division of the State Supreme Court, Presiding Justice of the Appellate Division of the State Supreme Court and Judge of the Court of Appeals. In 1990 he was named Deputy Mayor for Public Safety and Criminal Justice of the City of New York.

When allegations of corruption within the New York City Police Department were raised in 1992, Mollen was named Chairman of a special commission to investigate the problem and make recommendations for its elimination. After extensive investigation and study it determined that the NYPD had undergone alternating cycles of corruption and reform for many years. The Mollen Commission believed that the creation of an independent commission to monitor the anti-corruption activities of the Police Department, and help keep the NYPD vigilant in this area, would help break these cycles of corruption. Such a commission was established in 1995.

Mollen has received numerous honors and awards, including the Brooklyn Medical Center Founders Medal, the New York State Bar Association Award for Outstanding Judicial Contribution to the Criminal Justice System, the Distinguished Alumnus Award from the Office of the Corporation Counsel of the City of New York and the Governor's Council on Law Enforcement Distinguished Service Award.

Over the years, this distinguished jurist and devoted public servant has remained grateful to the University for the education and opportunities he received from alma mater. "I feel that I owe St. John's a lot," he said "and I try to reciprocate in my own way as much as I can."

He is a member of The Loughlin Society and serves as one of the judges of the Judge Milton Mollen Moot Court Competition, an annual event sponsored by the Moot Court Honor Society in which Honor Society members from the School of Law have a chance to hone their written and oral advocacy skills. St. John's University awarded him a Doctor of Laws, Honoris Causa, in 1978 and the School of Law presented him with the James Madison Award in 1990 and the Dean John J. Murphy Award in 1992. In May he was presented with the Medal of Honor at the University's 29th Annual Alumni Convocation.

"Life has been very good to me," he noted. "I've been very fortunate in so many ways, and one of the most pleasant areas of my life has been my connection to St. John's."